Mar 27, 2009

Is Nepal Heading Towards a Failed State?

By Deepak Gajurel International research organizations have concluded that Nepal's situation has been deteriorating and this nation is at the verge of being a failed state. Current political, economic and social indicators do not suggest hopeful situation for Nepal. An analysis on Nepal's present status was done by Political Scientist Deepak Gajurel. The analysis is based on internationally established norms and indicators which was broadcast live over Gorkha FM-93 Mhz on Chaitra 13, 2065. Please clink on the link below to listen or download the audio file in MP3 sound format. The audio file's size is 2.85 mb. http://www.box.net/shared/um5y3jlq3u Background information on failed state: The term failed state is often used by political commentators and journalists to describe a state perceived as having failed at some of the basic conditions and responsibilities of a sovereign government. In order to make this definition more precise, the following attributes, proposed by the Fund for Peace, are often used to characterize a failed state: loss of physical control of its territory, or of the monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force therein, erosion of legitimate authority to make collective decisions, an inability to provide reasonable public services, and an inability to interact with other states as a full member of the international community. Common characteristics of a failing state include a central government so weak or ineffective that it has little practical control over much of its territory; non-provision of public services; widespread corruption and criminality; refugees and involuntary movement of populations; and sharp economic decline [1]. The level of government control required to avoid being considered a failed state varies considerably amongst authorities.[2] Furthermore, the declaration that a state has "failed" is generally controversial and, when made authoritatively, may carry significant geopolitical consequences.[2] Definition A state could be said to "succeed" if it maintains, in the words of Max Weber, a monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force within its borders. When this is broken (e.g., through the dominant presence of warlords, paramilitary groups, or terrorism), the very existence of the state becomes dubious, and the state becomes a failed state. The difficulty of determining whether a government maintains "a monopoly on the legitimate use of force" (which includes the problems of the definition of "legitimate") means it is not clear precisely when a state can be said to have "failed." This problem of legitimacy can be solved by understanding what Weber intended by it. Weber clearly explains that only the state has the means of production necessary for physical violence (politics as vocation). This means that the state does not require legitimacy for achieving monopoly on the means of violence (de facto) but will need one if it needs to use it (de jure). The term is also used in the sense of a state that has been rendered ineffective (i.e., has nominal military/police control over its territory only in the sense of having no armed opposition groups directly challenging state authority; in short, the "no news is good news" approach) and is not able to enforce its laws uniformly because of high crime rates, extreme political corruption, an extensive informal market, impenetrable bureaucracy, judicial ineffectiveness, military interference in politics, cultural situations in which traditional leaders wield more power than the state over a certain area but do not compete with the state, or a number of other factors. [edit] Crisis States Research Centre The Crisis States Research Centre defines a “failed state” as a condition of “state collapse” – e.g. a state that can no longer perform its basic security and development functions and that has no effective control over its territory and borders. A failed state is one that can no longer reproduce the conditions for its own existence. This term is used in very contradictory ways in the policy community (for instance, there is a tendency to label a “poorly performing” state as “failed” – a tendency the Crisis States Research Centre rejects). The opposite of a “failed state” is an “enduring state” and the absolute dividing line between these two conditions is difficult to ascertain at the margins. Even in a failed state, some elements of the state, such as local state organisations, might continue to exist. Failed States Index Failed States according to Foreign Policy, 2005-2007 Since 2005 the United States think-tank, the Fund for Peace and the magazine Foreign Policy, publishes an annual index called the Failed States Index. The list only assesses sovereign states (determined by membership in the United Nations.)[3] Several territories are excluded until their political status and UN membership is ratified in international law. For example, Taiwan, the Palestinian Territories, Northern Cyprus, Kosovo, and Western Sahara are not included in the list, even though some are recognized as sovereign states by some nations. Ranking is based on the total scores of the 12 indicators (see below.) For each indicator, the ratings are placed on a scale of 0 to 10, with 0 being the lowest intensity (most stable) and 10 being the highest intensity (least stable). The total score is the sum of the 12 indicators and is on a scale of 0-120. Indicators of state vulnerability The index's ranks are based on twelve indicators of state vulnerability - four social, two economic and six political.[4] The indicators are not designed to forecast when states may experience violence or collapse. Instead, they are meant to measure a state's vulnerability to collapse or conflict. All countries in the red, orange, or yellow categories display some features that make parts of their societies and institutions vulnerable to failure. Some in the yellow zone may be failing at a faster rate than those in the more dangerous orange or red zones, and therefore could experience violence sooner. Conversely, some in the red zone, though critical, may exhibit some positive signs of recovery or be deteriorating slowly, giving them time to adopt mitigating strategies.[3] Social indicators Demographic pressures: including the pressures deriving from high population density relative to food supply and other life-sustaining resources. The pressure from a population's settlement patterns and physical settings, including border disputes, ownership or occupancy of land, access to transportation outlets, control of religious or historical sites, and proximity to environmental hazards.[5] Massive movement of refugees and internally displaced peoples: forced uprooting of large communities as a result of random or targeted violence and/or repression, causing food shortages, disease, lack of clean water, land competition, and turmoil that can spiral into larger humanitarian and security problems, both within and between countries.[6] Legacy of vengeance-seeking group grievance: based on recent or past injustices, which could date back centuries. Including atrocities committed with impunity against communal groups and/or specific groups singled out by state authorities, or by dominant groups, for persecution or repression. Institutionalized political exclusion. Public scapegoating of groups believed to have acquired wealth, status or power as evidenced in the emergence of "hate" radio, pamphleteering and stereotypical or nationalistic political rhetoric.[7] Chronic and sustained human flight: both the "brain drain" of professionals, intellectuals and political dissidents and voluntary emigration of "the middle class." Growth of exile/expat communities are also used as part of this indicator.[8] Economic indicators Uneven economic development along group lines: determined by group-based inequality, or perceived inequality, in education, jobs, and economic status. Also measured by group-based poverty levels, infant mortality rates, education levels.[9] Sharp and/or severe economic decline: measured by a progressive economic decline of the society as a whole (using: per capita income, GNP, debt, child mortality rates, poverty levels, business failures.) A sudden drop in commodity prices, trade revenue, foreign investment or debt payments. Collapse or devaluation of the national currency and a growth of hidden economies, including the drug trade, smuggling, and capital flight. Failure of the state to pay salaries of government employees and armed forces or to meet other financial obligations to its citizens, such as pension payments.[10] Political indicators Criminalization and/or delegitimisation of the state: endemic corruption or profiteering by ruling elites and resistance to transparency, accountability and political representation. Includes any widespread loss of popular confidence in state institutions and processes.[11] Progressive deterioration of public services: a disappearance of basic state functions that serve the people, including failure to protect citizens from terrorism and violence and to provide essential services, such as health, education, sanitation, public transportation. Also using the state apparatus for agencies that serve the ruling elites, such as the security forces, presidential staff, central bank, diplomatic service, customs and collection agencies.[12] Widespread violation of human rights: an emergence of authoritarian, dictatorial or military rule in which constitutional and democratic institutions and processes are suspended or manipulated. Outbreaks of politically inspired (as opposed to criminal) violence against innocent civilians. A rising number of political prisoners or dissidents who are denied due process consistent with international norms and practices. Any widespread abuse of legal, political and social rights, including those of individuals, groups or cultural institutions (e.g., harassment of the press, politicization of the judiciary, internal use of military for political ends, public repression of political opponents, religious or cultural persecution.)[13] Security apparatus as ‘state within a state’: an emergence of elite or praetorian guards that operate with impunity. Emergence of state-sponsored or state-supported private militias that terrorize political opponents, suspected "enemies," or civilians seen to be sympathetic to the opposition. An "army within an army" that serves the interests of the dominant military or political clique. Emergence of rival militias, guerilla forces or private armies in an armed struggle or protracted violent campaigns against state security forces.[14] Rise of factionalised elites: a fragmentation of ruling elites and state institutions along group lines. Use of aggressive nationalistic rhetoric by ruling elites, especially destructive forms of communal irredentism (e.g., "Greater Serbia") or communal solidarity (e.g., "ethnic cleansing", "defending the faith").[15] Intervention of other states or external factors: military or Para-military engagement in the internal affairs of the state at risk by outside armies, states, identity groups or entities that affect the internal balance of power or resolution of the conflict. Intervention by donors, especially if there is a tendency towards over-dependence on foreign aid or peacekeeping missions.[16] http://www.box.net/shared/um5y3jlq3u

Mar 13, 2009

Nepal in a Political Deadlock: Is there any Way Out?

Ruling Maoist leaders have created an uproar that 'a conspiracy is under way in India to restore Monarchy' in Nepal. Girija Prasad Koirala is in India, so are some UML leaders. Former King Gyanendra too is in India since last two weeks. Koirala is scheduled to meet Indian prime minister, Sonia Gandhi, BJP top leaders and others. This has created skepticism that some kind of regime change in Nepal is being planned in New Delhi. What would be the reality? Is Nepal's political scenario going to change? In the past, India had been doing 'what it wanted' in Nepal. But the situation has changed now and India's power has been checked in Kathmandu by China and the United States. Can India do 'anything' it desires in Nepal? In the domestic front, the nation is crippled by continued 'struggles' by various forces. The ruling parties are signaling to amend the Interim Constitution to meet the demands of Tharus. On the other hand, Madheshis are threatening the government not to undermine 'Madhesh' or face another Madhesh Aandolan. You go with one, there is another against it. The rulers and leaders have deliberately engulfed the nation into political chaos. There seems no way out. What would be the political picture of Nepal in the days to come? Can the leaders find easy way out? Who is responsible for this situation? An in-depth analysis is done in a radio talk-show by Deepak Gajurel, Assistant Professor of Political Science, Tribhuvan University. The program was broadcast live over Gorkha FM (93 Mhz) on Fagun 29, 2065. Please click the following link to listen/download the talk show. Feedback would be appreciated. http://www.box.net/shared/uaxykn9skt

Mar 8, 2009

India's Involvement in Nepali Politics: Are Nepali Political Parties Steered by India?

By Deepak Gajurel Indian foreign minister, also acting Prime Minister, Pranav Mukharjee, in an interview with Al Zajeera Television, announced that India officially 'persuaded' Maoists and Nepali political parties to sign 12 point agreement in New Delhi. It is the first time an Indian high ranking official publicly accepted that India has a key role in Nepal's internal political affairs. Since the signing of 12 point agreement, India has had rejected its any direct involvement in Nepal's peace process. What does this disclosure from Indian side mean for Nepali current peace process? Why did New Delhi choose this time for revealing this fact? Does it mean that India's Nepal policy and strategy heading towards failure? What would be the consequences of India's policy failure in Nepal? Is the current peace process going to derail? Is India pressurizing Maoists and 'Parliamentary' parties to work in accordance with India's will? If yes, what are the possible factors behind India's concerns? Before the signing of Delhi agreement, was India bargaining with the King as well as with the Maoists/seven parties simultaneously? The parties of 12 point agreement (Maoists and seven parties) seems to have derailed from the 'consensus.' What would be consenquences? Where Nepal is heading? I have analyze whole gamut of the issues to dig out answers to these questions in a radio talk show. The program was broadcast live over Gorkha FM on Magh 17, 2065. Please click on the link below to listen/download the program. I would appreciate if you could find time to provide me feedback on the same. Deepak Gajurel Assistant Professor Tribhuvan University http://www.box.net/shared/ty3i5tljaa

Mar 7, 2009

China's Security Concerns in Nepal

By Deepak Gajurel Since the establishment of Nepal-China diplomatic relations in 1955, China, for the first time, sent its Special Envoy to Nepal. China has proposed a new Peace and Friendship Treaty with Nepal. A big hue and cry was seen in Kathmandu on China's unconventional 'open' diplomatic moves in recent days. Beijing's recent moves have created huge political and academic interpretations in Nepal. Taking part in a radio talk show, I have analyzed China's major concerns and Beijing's possible future strategies in and from Nepal. The talk show was broadcast live over Gorkha FM on Fagun 16, 2065. Please click on the link below to listen or download the program in MP3 format. http://www.box.net/shared/0fjt58hk5j I would appreciate if you could find time to listen the analysis and provide me your feedback.

US and Nepal; Sri Lanka-Meaning for Nepal

By Deepak Gajurel United States has been showing serious interests in Nepal since the political change three years back. US officials are frequently visiting Nepal which is getting utmost attention among Nepal intelligentsia and diplomats in Kathmandu. US Under Secretary of States Boucher's recent visit to Kathmandu made an issue for academic and diplomatic discussions. As an Assistant Professor of Political Science with Tribhuvan University, with special interests on international power equation and Nepal's relations with friendly nations, I have analyzed the US concerns in Nepal in a live radio talk show. What Washington wants in Nepal? Is Nepal engulfed into regional and international power struggle? What should be the strategy of Nepal to serve its national interests? I have tried to explore answers to these questions in the radio interview. The talk show was broadcast over Gorkha FM on Fagun 2, 2065. The program also includes recent development in Sri Lanka and its possible meaning for Nepal. Please click on the link below to listen or download the audio file (MP3) http://www.box.net/shared/lff45j0079

Mar 5, 2009

рдоुрд▓ुрдХ рдлेрд░ि рднीрдбрди्рдд рддрд░्рдл рдЙрди्рдоुрдЦ

рджीрдкрдХ рдЧрдЬुрд░ेрд▓ рдоुрд▓ुрдХрдХो рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддि рдХрддा рдЬाँрджैрдЫ ? рдЕрд╡ рдХे рд╣ुрдиे рд╣ो ? рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рд╢рдХ्рддिрд╣рд░ु рдмीрдЪ рдЪрд▓िрд░ाрдЦेрдХो рдЕрд╣िрд▓ेрдХो рдж्рд╡рди्рдж्рд╡рдХो рдкрд░िрдгाрдо рдХे рд╣ुрдиे рд╣ो ? рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓े рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рд╕्рдеाрдпिрдд्рд╡ рдХрд╣िрд▓े рд░ рдХрд╕рд░ी рдкाрдЙрдиे рд╣ो ? рдпी рдк्рд░рд╢्рдирд╣рд░ु рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдЖрдо рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрдХा рдордирдоा рдЧрдо्рднीрд░ рд░ुрдкрд▓े рдЙрдаेрдХा рдЫрди् । рд░ाрдЬाрдХो рд╢ाрд╕рди рд╡िрд░ुрдж्рдз рдЖрди्рджोрд▓рдирдХो рдиेрддृрдд्рд╡ рдЧрд░ेрдХा рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рд╢рдХ्рддीрд╣рд░ु рджिрд╢ाрдмिрд╣ीрди рдЕрдмрд╕्рдеाрдоा рдкुрдЧेрдХो рджेрдЦिрди्рдЫ । рдоुрд▓ुрдХрдоा рдк्рд░рдЬाрддрди्рдд्рд░ рд░ рд╕्рдеाрдпिрдд्рд╡ рджिрдиे рддрдеा рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрдХो рд╢ाрд╕рди рд╕्рдеाрдкिрдд рдЧрд░्рдиे рд▓рдХ्рд╖्рдпрдХा рд╕ाрде рдПрдХ рдЬुрдЯ рднрдПрдХा рджрд▓ рддрдеा рд╢рдХ्рддिрд╣рд░ु рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рд╡िрднाрдЬिрдд рднрдПрдХा рдЫрди् । рдкрд░िрдгाрдорд╕्рд╡рд░ुрдк, рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рдоाрдд्рд░ рд╣ोрдЗрди, рдЖрд░्рдеिрдХ, рд╕ाрдоाрдЬिрдХ, рд╢ैрдХ्рд╖िрдХ, рдХूрдЯрдиीрддिрдХ рд▓рдЧाрдпрддрдХा рд╕рдмै рдХ्рд╖ेрдд्рд░ рдЕрд╕्рддрд╡्рдпрд╕्рдд рдмрди्рдирдкुрдЧेрдХा рдЫрди् । рдЖрдо рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрд▓े рдПрдХ рдкрдЫि рдЕрд░्рдХो рдЧрд░्рджै рдЕрдиेрдХौँ рджु:рдЦ рдХрд╖्рдЯ рдЦेрдк्рдиु рдкрд░ेрдХो рдЫ । рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХा рд╕ाрде рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рд╕рд╣ी рджिрд╢ा рджिрдиे рдк्рд░рддिрдмрдж्рдзрддा рд╡्рдпрдХ्рдд рдЧрд░्рдиेрд╣рд░ुрд╡ाрдЯ рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХ рдиिрд░ाрд╢ рдмрди्рджै рдЧрдПрдХा рдЫрди् । рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХो рдЕрди्рдд्рдп : рд╡िрд╢्рд╡ рд╕рдоुрджाрдпрд▓े рд╕्рдеाрдкिрдд рдЧрд░ेрдХा рдк्рд░рдЬाрддाрди्рдд्рд░िрдХ рдоूрд▓्рдп–рдоाрди्рдпрддा, рдХाрдиुрдирдХो рд╢ाрд╕рди рдЬрд╕्рддा рдк्рд░рдХृрдпा рдк्рд░рддि рдЖрд╕्рдеा рд░ाрдЦ्рдиे рдПрдХ рдерд░ी рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рджрд▓ рдЫрди् । рдЕрд░्рдХा рдерд░ी рдЫрди्, рдмрди्рджूрдХрдХो рдмрд▓рдоा рд╕рдд्рддा рдХрдм्рдЬा рдЧрд░्рдиे рд╕िрдж्рдзाрди्рдд рд░ рд░рдгрдиीрддि рдмोрдХेрдХा । рдпी рджुрдИрд▓े рдПрдХ рдЕрд░्рдХा рд╕ंрдЧ рдоिрд▓ेрд░ рдиेрдкाрд▓рдоा рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рд╕्рдеाрдпिрдд्рд╡ рджिрди्рдЫौँ рднрдиेрдХा рдеिрдП рддीрди рд╡рд░्рд╖ рдЕрдШि । рдд्рдпрд╕рдмेрд▓ाрдХो рдк्рд░рддिрдмрдж्рдзрддाрдоा рдмрд╣ुрджрд▓ीрдп рдк्рд░рддिрд╖्рдк्рд░рд░्рдзाрдд्рдордХ рд╢ाрд╕рди рдк्рд░рдгाрд▓ी рд╕्рдеाрдкрдиा рдЧрд░्рдиे рд╕рд╣рдорддि рднрдПрдХो рдеिрдпो । рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рд░ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рдоिрд▓ेрд░ рдЖрди्рджोрд▓рдирдХो рдиेрддृрдд्рд╡ рдЧрд░े, рджेрд╢рдоा рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рдкрд░िрд╡рд░्рддрди рднрдпो рд░ рд░ाрдЬрддрди्рдд्рд░ рдЕрди्рдд्рдп рднрдПрд░ рдоुрд▓ुрдХрдоा рдЧрдгрддрди्рдд्рд░ рдЖрдпो । рдЕрд╡ рдирдпाँ рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрди рдмрдиाрдПрд░ рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рджिрдиे рдЬिрдо्рдоेрд╡ाрд░ी рдкूрд░ा рдЧрд░्рди рдмाँрдХी рдЫ । рддрд░ рд╕्рдеिрддिрд▓े рдХोрд▓्рдЯे рдлेрд░ेрдХो рдЫ । рдоिрд▓ेрд░ рдЬाрдиे рд╕рд╣рдорддि рдЧрд░ेрдХा рд╢рдХ्рддिрд╣рд░ु рдмीрдЪ рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХो рд╕ंрд╕्рдХाрд░ рдЕрди्рдд्рдп рднрдПрдХो рдЫ । рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░िрдп рд╕рд╣рдорддि рдХाрдпрдо рдЧрд░ी рд╕рдмै рдиेрдкाрд▓ी рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрдоा рд╕्рд╡ाрдоिрдд्рд╡рдХो рднाрд╡рдиा рд╡िрдХрд╕िрдд рд╣ुрдиे рдЦाрд▓рдХो рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрди рдмрдиाрдЙрдиु рдкрд░्рдиे рдмेрд▓ाрдоा рдЬрдирддाрдХो рдиेрддृрдд्рд╡ рдЧрд░्рдиेрд╣рд░ु рдиै рдЖрдкрд╕ी рдж्рд╡рди्рдж्рд╡рдоा рдЕрд▓्рдЭेрдХा рдЫрди् । рдиिрдпрдоिрдд рд╕ंрд╕рджीрдп рдХाрд░्рдпрдк्рд░рдгाрд▓ीрдоा рдЬрд╕्рддो рдЧрд░ी рд╕рдд्рддाрдкрдХ्рд╖ рд░ рдк्рд░рддिрдкрдХ्рд╖рдХो рднूрдоिрдХा рджेрдЦाрдЙрдиे рдмेрд▓ा рд╣ोрдЗрди рдпो । рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрди рдмрдиाрдЙрди рдаोрд╕ рд░ुрдкрд▓े рдХाрдо рдЧрд░्рдиुрдХो рд╕ाрдЯो рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рджрд▓рд╣рд░ु рднीрдбрди्рддрдоा рд▓ाрдЧ्рдиु рдоुрд▓ुрдХрдХा рд▓ाрдЧि рджुрд░्рднाрдЧ्рдп рд╣ो । реирежремреи рд╕ाрд▓ рдоंрд╕िрд░рдоा рднाрд░рддрд▓े рдЧрд░ाрдЗрджिрдПрдХो рд╕рдо्рдЭौрддाрдХा рдкрдХ्рд╖рд╣рд░ु рдмीрдЪ рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рджेрдЦाрдкрд░ेрдХो рдж्рд╡рди्рдж्рд╡ рдпрд╕рдмेрд▓ाрдХो рдЖрд╡рд╢्рдпрдХрддाрдХा рд╣िрд╕ाрдмрд▓े рдЕрдиाрд╡рд╢्рдпрдХ рд▓ाрдЧ्рди рд╕рдХ्рдЫ рддрд░ рдпो рдЕрд╕्рд╡рднाрд╡िрдХ рдЪाрд╣िँ рд╣ोрдЗрди । 'рдоिрд▓ेрд░ рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддि рдЧрд░्рдиे рд╡िрд╖рдпрдоा рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХा рд╕ाрде рдЬाрдиे рдЧुрдЮ्рдЬाрдЗрд╕ рдиै рдеिрдПрди рд░ рдЫैрди рдпिрдиीрд╣рд░ु рдмीрдЪ । рдХिрдирднрдиे рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рднрдиिрдиे рджрд▓рд╣рд░ु рд░ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрдмीрдЪ рдЖрдзाрд░рднूрдд рд╕िрдж्рдзाрди्рдд, рд░рдгрдиीрддि рд░ рд╢ैрд▓ीрдоा рдиै рд╡िрдкрд░िрдд рдз्рд░ुрд╡ीрдп рднिрди्рдирддा рдЫ । рд╡िрдЪाрд░ рд░ рдХрд░्рдордХो рд╕्рд╡рддрди्рдд्рд░рддा рд╕рд╣िрддрдХो рдЦुрд▓ा рддрдеा рдЙрджाрд░ рдк्рд░рдЬाрддाрди्рдд्рд░िрдХ рдк्рд░рдгाрд▓ीрд▓ाрдИ рдЕрдЩ्рдЧिрдХाрд░ рдЧрд░्рдиे рдкрдХ्рд╖ рд░ рдЖрдлू рдмाрд╣ेрдХ рд╕рдмै 'рдЬрдирддाрдХा рд╢рдд्рд░ु' рд╣ुрди्‍ рднрдиेрд░ рдЕрд░ुрдХो рдЕрд╕्рддिрдд्рд╡ рдиै рд╕्рд╡ीрдХाрд░ рдирдЧрд░्рдиेे рдиीрддिрдХा рдЕрдиुрдпाрдпी рдПрдХै рдаाрдЙँрдоा рдмрд╕्рдиे рд░ рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рдХा рд▓ाрдЧि рд╕ंрдЧै рдХाрдо рдЧрд░्рдиे рдХुрд░ा рд╕्рд╡ेрд░ рдХрд▓्рдкрдиा рдоाрдд्рд░ рд╣ो । рдпрд╕ рдЖрдзाрд░рднूрдд рдоाрди्рдпрддाрдХा рдЖрдзाрд░рдоा рд╡िрд╢्рд▓ेрд╖рдг рдЧрд░्рджा рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рджрд▓ рд░ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рдПрдХ рдЕрд░्рдХाрдХा рд╢рдд्рд░ुрдХा рд░ुрдкрдоा рдЦрдбा рд╣ुрдиु рд╕्рд╡рднाрд╡िрдХ рддрдеा рдк्рд░ाрдХृрддिрдХ рд╣ो । рдпो рдЕрд╕्рд╡рднाрд╡िрдХрддाрд▓ाрдИ рдХेрд╣ी рд╕рдордп рдвाрдХрдЫोрдк рдЧрд░िрдПрдХो рдеिрдпो । рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдпो рд╡ाрд╕्рддрд╡िрдХрддा рд╕рддрд╣рдоा рдЖрдПрдХो рдоाрдд्рд░ рд╣ो । рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рдвाँрдЯिрдпो: рдк्рд░рдгрд╡ рдоुрдЦрд░्рдЬीрд▓े 'рдордиाрдПрд░' резреи рдмुँрджे рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдоा рд╣рд╕्рддाрдХ्рд╖рд░ рдЧрд░्рдиे рджुрдмै рдкрдХ्рд╖ рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдПрдХ рдЕрд░्рдХा рдк्рд░рддि рдзाрд░े рд╣ाрдд рдЧрд░्рджैрдЫрди्‍ । рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рджрд▓рд╣рд░ुрд▓े рд╕рд╣рдорддि рддोрдбेрдХो рд╕рдкाрдЯ рдЖрд░ोрдк рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрдХो рдЫ рднрдиे, рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХो рдкाрд▓рдиा рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े 'рд╢ुрд░ु рджेрдЦि рдиै рдирдЧрд░ेрдХो' рдЖрд░ोрдк рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджीрдХो рдЫ । 'рдЖрддрдЩ्рдХрдХाрд░ीрд▓ाрдИ рдоूрд▓рдзाрд░рдХो рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдоा рд╕рдлрд▓рддाрдкूрд░्рд╡рдХ рд▓्рдпाрдПँ' рднрдиेрд░ рджाрд╡ी рдЧрд░्рдиे рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рдЦेрдоाрдХा рдиेрддा рдЧिрд░िрдЬाрдк्рд░рд╕ाрдж рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी 'рдЕрдзिрдиाрдпрдХрд╡ाрджी рдмрдиेрдХो' рд░ 'рд╕рд╣рдорддिрд╣рд░ु рдкाрд▓рдиा рдирдЧрд░ेрдХो' рдЖрд░ोрдк рд▓ाрдЙँрджैрдЫрди्‍ । рдЙрдиी рдк्рд░рдзाрдирдорди्рдд्рд░ी рд╣ुँрджा 'рдЖрддрдЩ्рдХрдХाрд░ी' рд▓ाрдИ рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдоा рд▓्рдпाрдЙрди рд╕рдлрд▓рддा рдк्рд░ाрдк्рдд рдЧрд░ेрдХो рднрдП рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдХिрди рдпрд╕्рддो рднрдПрдХो ? рд╕рдо्рдмрди्рдзिрддрд▓े рдЬрд╡ाрдл рджिрдиुрдкрд░्рдЫ । рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े резреи рдмुँрджे рджिрд▓्рд▓ी рд╕рдо्рдЭौрддा рд░ рдд्рдпрд╕рдкрдЫि рднрдП рдЧрд░ेрдХा рдХुрдиै рдкрдиि рд╕рд╣рдорддि рдкाрд▓рдиा рдЧрд░ेрдХो рдЫैрди рднрди्рдиे рдЖрд░ोрдк рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рдвाँрдЯ्‍рдиे рд░ рдЪाрд▓рдмाрдЬी рдЧрд░्рдиे рд░рдгाрдиीрддि рдоाрдд्рд░ рд╣ो । рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рдиेрддाрд▓े рднрдиे рдЬрд╕рд░ी рдпрджि рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े рдЖрд░рдо्рдн рджेрдЦि рдиै рд╕рд╣рдорддिрд╣рд░ु рдЙрд▓рдЩ्рдШрди рдЧрд░ेрдХा рд╣ुрди्‍ рднрдиे рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рдк्рд░рдХृрдпाрдоा рдЙрдиीрд╣рд░ुрд▓ाрдИ рдпрд╕рд░ी рдЕрдШि рдмрдв्‍рди рдХिрди рджिрдЗрдпो ? рдкुрди рд╕्рдеाрдкिрдд рдк्рд░рддिрдиिрдзिрд╕рднाрдоा рдордиोрдиिрдд рдЧрд░ेрд░ рд╕рдд्рддा рд╕рдЮ्рдЪाрд▓рдирдоा рд▓ाрдиे рдмेрд▓ाрдоा рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рдоूрд▓рдзाрд░рдоा рдЖрдЗрд╕рдХेрдХा рдеिрдП рдХि ? рдпрджि рдеिрдПрдирди्‍ рднрдиे рдд्рдпрд╕ैрдмेрд▓ा рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рдпрдеाрд░्рде рдЬाрдирдХाрд░ी рдХिрди рджिрдЗрдПрди ? рдЙрдиीрд╣рд░ुрд▓ाрдИ рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрдирд╕рднाрдХो рдЪुрдиाрд╡рдоा рд╕рд╣рднाрдЧी рдЧрд░ाрдЙрдиु рдЕрдШि рдЬрдирддाрд▓ाрдИ рд╕ूрдЪिрдд рдХिрди рдЧрд░िрдПрди, рдпिрдирд▓े рд╕рд╣рдорддि рдХाрд░्рдпाрди्рд╡рдпрди рдЧрд░ेрдХा рдЫैрдирди्‍ рд░ рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рдк्рд░рдХृрдпा рдЕрдкрдиाрдПрдХा рдЫैрдирди्‍ рднрдиेрд░ ? рд╕рд░рдХाрд░рдХो рдиेрддृрдд्рд╡ рд╣рд╕्рддाрди्рддрд░рдг рдЧрд░िрд╕рдХ्рджा рд╕рдоेрдд 'рдЖрддрдЩ्рдХрдХाрд░ीрд▓ाрдИ рд╢ाрди्рддिрдкूрд░्рдг рдк्рд░рдЬाрддाрди्рдд्рд░िрдХ рдк्рд░рдХृрдпाрдоा рд▓्рдпाрдПँ' рднрдиेрд░ рджाрд╡ी рдЧрд░्рдиेрд▓े рдпрд╕рдмेрд▓ा 'рд╢ुрд░ु рджेрдЦि рдиै рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХो рд╕ंрд╕्рдХृрддि рдирдЕрдкрдиाрдПрдХो' рдЖрд░ोрдк рд▓рдЧाрдЙрдиु рднрдиेрдХो рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рдвाँрдЯ्‍рдиु рд╣ो, рдЬрдирддा рддिрдоी рднेँрдбा рд╣ौ рднрди्рдиु рд╣ो । рдпрд╕ рд╕рди्рджрд░्рднрдоा рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рдзेрд░ैрд╣рдж рд╕рдо्рдо рдЗрдоाрди्рджाрд░ рджेрдЦिрди्рдЫ, рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддिрдХ рд░ुрдкрдоा । рд╕рд░्рд╡рд╣ाрд░ाрд╡рд░्рдЧрдХो рдЕрдзिрдиाрдпрдХрдд्рд╡рдХो рд╕्рдеाрдкрдиा рдмрди्рджूрдХрдХो рдиाрд▓рд╡ाрдЯ рдЧрд░्рдиे рдЙрдж्‍рдШोрд╖рдХाрд╕ाрде рд╕рд╢рд╕्рдд्рд░ рд╕ंрдШрд░्рд╖рдоा рдЧрдПрдХो рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдкрдиि рдд्рдпो рд▓рдХ्рд╖्рдп рдд्рдпाрдЧेрдХो рдЫैрди । резреи рдмुँрджे рд╕рдо्рдЭौрддा рдЕрдШि рджेрдЦि рдиै рд╕ैрдж्рдзाрди्рддिрдХ рддрдеा рд╡्рдпрд╡рд╣ाрд░िрдХ рд░ुрдкрдоा рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े рдЬे рднрди्рджै рдЖрдПрдХो рдеिрдпो, рд╡्рдпрд╡рд╣ाрд░рдоा рдаीрдХ рдд्рдпрд╣ी рдЧрд░्рджै рдЖрдПрдХो рдЫ, рдЖрд░рдо्рднрджेрдЦि рдЖрдЬ рд╕рдо्рдо । рд╣ाрдо्рд░ो рдпुрдж्рдз рд╕рдХिрдПрдХो рдЫैрди, рд╡िрдж्рд░ोрд╣ рдЧрд░्рдЫौँ, рд╕рдд्рддा рдХрдм्рдЬा рдЧрд░्рдЫौँ, рд╣ाрдоीрд▓ाрдИ рдмाрдзा рдкुрд░्‍рдпाрдЙрдиेрдХो рдвाрдб рднाँрдЪिрджिрди्рдЫौँ рдЬрд╕्рддा рднाрд╖ाрдг рдоाрдд्рд░ рдЖрдЗрд░ाрдЦेрдХा рдЫैрдирди्‍ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд╡ाрдЯ । рдЙрдиीрд╣рд░ुрдХो рдЖрдзिрдХाрд░िрдХ рдкाрд░्рдЯी рджрд╕्рддाрдмेрдЬрд╣рд░ुрдоा рдиै рдХрдо्рдпूрдиिрд╖्рдЯ рдкाрд░्рдЯीрдХो рд╕рд░्рд╡рд╕рдд्рддाрд╡ाрдж рд╕्рдеाрдкрдиा рдЧрд░्рдиे рд▓рдХ्рд╖्рдп рд╕्рдкрд╖्рдЯ рдЙрд▓्рд▓ेрдЦ рдЫ । рдЖрдл्рдиो рдкрдЫि рдирд▓ाрдЧ्рдиे рд╡ा рд╡िрд░ोрдз рдЧрд░्рдиेрд▓ाрдИ 'рдаेрдЧाрди' рд▓ाрдЙрдиे рд╢ैрд▓ी рд▓िрдЦिрдд, рдоौрдЦिрдХ рд░ рд╡्рдпрд╡рд╣ाрд░िрдХ рд╕рдмै рддрд╣рдоा рдЙрд╕ैрдмेрд▓ा рджेрдЦि рдЬाрд░ी рдЫ । рдХрдм्рдЬा рдЧрд░िрдПрдХा рд╕рдо्рдкрддि рдлिрд░्рддा рдЧрд░्рджैрдиौँ рднрди्рдиे рдЬрдиाрдЙ рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрди рд╕рднाрдХो рдЪुрдиाрд╡ рднрди्рджा рдзेрд░ै рдЕрдШि рджेрдЦि рдиै рдЖрдПрдХो рд╣ो । рдмिрдЧрддрдХा рдпी рддрде्рдпрд╡ाрдЯ рдХे рд╕्рдкрд╖्рдЯ рд╣ुрди्рдЫ рднрдиे, рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рднрдиिрдиे рдХुрдиै рдкрдиि рдиेрддा рд╡ा рдкाрд░्рдЯीрд▓ाрдИ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрдоाрдеि рд╕рд╣рдорддि рдЕрдиुрд░ुрдк рдЪрд▓ेрдирди्‍ рднрди्рдиे рдЖрд░ोрдк рд▓рдЧाрдЙрдиे рдЕрдзिрдХाрд░ рдЫैрди । рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рд╢ैрд▓ीрдХो рд╡िрд░ुрдж्рдз рдЦрдбा рд╣ुрдиेрд╣рд░ुрд▓े рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░ рддрдеा рдЬрдирддाрд▓ाрдИ рдвाँрдЯेрдХा рд╣ुрди्‍, рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░ рд╡िрд░ुрдж्рдз рдЬाрд▓рд╕ाрдЬी рдЧрд░ेрдХा рд╣ुрди्‍ । рдлेрд░ि рднीрдбрди्рдд ? 'рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдХो рд╡ाрдЯो рдЫाрдб्‍рдпो' рднрди्рдиे рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджीрд╣рд░ु рд░ 'рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджीрд╣рд░ु рд╕рд╣рдорддिрдоा рд╣िँрдб्‍рди рдЪाрд╣ेрдирди्‍' рднрди्рдиे рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рдЕрд╡ рдЖ–рдЖрдл्рдиै рд╡ाрдЯो рд▓ाрдЧेрдХा рдЫрди्‍ । рдЕрдз्рдпाрджेрд╢ рдк्рд░рдХрд░рдг, рд╕ेрдиा рд╕рдоाрдпोрдЬрди, рд╕ेрдиाрдоा рднрд░्рддी, рдХрдм्рдЬा рдЧрд░िрдПрдХा рд╕рдо्рдкрддि рдлिрд░्рддा рд▓рдЧाрдпрддрдХा рд╡िрд╖рдп рдд рд╕рддрд╣рдоा рджेрдЦिрдиे рддрдкрд╕िрд▓рдХा рдорддрднिрди्рдирддा рдоाрдд्рд░ рд╣ुрди्‍ । рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े резреи рдмुँрджे рджिрд▓्рд▓ी рд╕рдо्рдЭौрддा рд░ рдд्рдпрд╕рдкрдЫिрдХा рд╕рд╣рдорддिрд╣рд░ुрд▓ाрдИ рдЙрдкेрдХ्рд╖ा рдЧрд░्рджै рдмрд▓рдоिрдЪ्рдпाрдЗँрдж्рд╡ाрд░ा рдЖрдлैँ рд╕рд░्рд╡ेेрд╕рд░्рдмा рд╣ुрди рдЦोрдЬ्рджैрдЫ рднрди्рдиे рдХुрд░ा рдк्рд░рддि рдЖрдо рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрдоा, рдХрдорд╕ेрдХрдо рдмौрдж्рдзिрдХ рдЬрдЧрддрдоा, рд▓рдЧрднрдЧ рд╕рд╣рдорддि рджेрдЦिрди्рдЫ । рдЕрд░्рдХाрддिрд░, рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрдХो рд╢рдХ्рддिрд▓ाрдИ рдЙрдкрдпोрдЧ рдЧрд░ेрд░ рд░ाрдЬ्рдп рд╕рдд्рддाрдоा рдЖрдл्рдиो рд╣ाрд▓िрдоुрд╣ाрд▓ी рдХाрдпрдо рдЧрд░्рдиे рдЕрднिрд╖्рдЯ рдкूрд░ा рдирд╣ुрдиे рдЕрдмрд╕्рдеा рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рдк्рд░рдоुрдЦ рджрд▓рд╣рд░ुрд▓े рджेрдЦ्рди рдеाрд▓ेрдХा рдЫрди्‍ । рдЖрдл्рдиो рдиिрд╣िрдд рд╕्рд╡ाрд░्рде рдкूрд░ा рд╣ुрдиे рд╕рдо्рднाрд╡рдиा рдШрдЯ्‍рджै рдЧрдПрдХो рджेрдЦ्рдиे, рдоुрд▓ुрдХ рд░ рдЬрдирддाрдХा рднाрдЧ्рдп рдиिрд░्рдоाрддा рдмрди्рди рдкुрдЧेрдХा рдпी рджुрдИ рдз्рд░ुрд╡ीрдп рд╢рдХ्рддिрд╣рд░ु рдЕрд╡рдХा рджिрдирдоा рд╕ंрдЧै рд╣िँрдб्‍рдиे рд╕рдо्рднाрд╡рдиा рд╕рдХिрдПрдХो рдЫ । рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рджрд▓рд╣рд░ुрд▓े реирежрекрен рд╕ाрд▓рдХो рд╕ंрдмिрдзाрди рдЕрдиुрд╕ाрд░ рд╢ाрд╕рди рдЪрд▓ाрдЙँрджाрдХो рдмрдЦрдд рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджीрд▓े рдд्рдпрд╣ी рд╡्рдпрдмрд╕्рдеाрдХा рд╡िрд░ुрдж्рдз рдмрди्рджूрдХ рдЙрдаाрдПрдХो рд╣ो । рдЖрдл्рдиो рд╕िрдж्рдзाрди्рдд рд░ рд╡्рдпрд╡рд╣ाрд░рд╡ाрдЯ рдбेрдЧ рдирдЪрд▓ेрдХो рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рд░ рдЬрдирддाрд▓ाрдИ рдн्рд░рдордоा рд░ाрдЦ्рдиे рддрдеा рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░рд▓ाрдИ рдвाँрдЯ्‍рдиे рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджीрд╣рд░ु рд╕ैрдж्рдзाрди्рддिрдХ рдЕрдиि рдоौрдЦिрдХ рд╣िрд╕ाрдмрд▓े рдЖрдордиे–рд╕ाрдордиे рднीрдбрди्рддрдоा рдЫрди्‍ рдпрд╕рдмेрд▓ा । рдкрдЫाрдбि рдлрд░्рдХрди рдирд╕рдХ्рдиे рдмिрди्рджुрдоा рдкुрдЧिрд╕рдХेрдХा рдЫрди्‍ рдпी рджुрдмै । реирежремрез рд╕ाрд▓рдоा рд░ाрдЬाрд▓े рд╕рдо्рдкूрд░्рдг рд╕рдд्рддा рд╣ाрддрдоा рд▓िрдиु рдЕрдШि рд╕ंрд╕рджрд╡ाрджी рдкрдХ्рд╖ рд░ рдоाрдУрд╡ाрджी рдЬुрди рд╕्рдеिрддिрдоा рдеिрдП рдЕрд╣िрд▓े рдлेрд░ि рдд्рдпрд╣ी рдЕрдмрд╕्рдеाрдоा рдкुрдЧेрдХा рдЫрди्‍, рд╣рддिрдпाрд░ рдЪрд▓्рди рдоाрдд्рд░ рдмाँрдХी рдЫ । рд░ рдд्рдпрд╕рдХो рд╕рдо्рднाрд╡рдиा рдмрдв्‍рджै рдЧрдПрдХो рдЫ । рдХुрди рдмрд╣ाрдиाрдоा, рдХुрди рдмेрд▓ा рд░ рдХрд╕рд░ी рдмिрд╖्рдлोрдЯ рд╣ुрдиे рд╣ो рднрди्рдиे рдд्рд░ाрд╕ рдмрдв्‍рджै рдЧрдПрдХो рдЫ । рдПрдХ рджрд╢рдХрдХो рднрдпाрдирдХ рд╣िँрд╕ा, рд░ाрд╖्рдЯ्рд░ рд░ рдиाрдЧрд░िрдХрд▓ाрдИ рднोрдЧाрдЗрдПрдХा рдЕрдХрд▓्рдкрдиीрдп рдкीрдбा, рд░ाрдЬाрдХो рдиिрд░ंрдХुрд╢рддा рд░ рдЕрд░ाрдЬрдХрддाрд╡ाрдЯ 'рд╢ाрди्рддि рдк्рд░рдХृрдпा' рд▓े рдоुрдХ्рддि рджेрд▓ा рднрди्рдиे рдиेрдкाрд▓ी рдЬрдирддाрдХो рдЖрд╢ा рдиिрд░ाрд╢ाрдоा рдкрд░िрдгрдд рд╣ुँрджैрдЫ । рдд्рдпрд╕्рддो рднрдпाрд╡рд╣ рдЕрдмрд╕्рдеाрд▓ाрдИ рдоुрд▓ुрдХрд▓े рдЕрдм рдХрд╕рд░ी рдеेрдЧ्рдиे рд╣ो, рд╕्рдеिрддि рдХрд╣ाрд▓ी рд▓ाрдЧ्рджो рдЫ । deepakgajurel@gmail.com рдЧрдЬुрд░ेрд▓ рдд्рд░िрднूрд╡рди рд╡िрд╢्рд╡рд╡िрдж्рдпाрд▓рдпрдоा рд░ाрдЬрдиीрддि рд╢ाрд╕्рдд्рд░рдХा рдЙрдкрдк्рд░ाрдз्рдпाрдкрдХ рд╣ुрди् । рдирдпाँ рдкрдд्рд░िрдХा рджैрдиिрдХрдоा рдк्рд░рдХाрд╢िрдд, рдлाрдЧुрди резрек, реирежремрел